How Do You Measure Spiritual Growth?

American love to measure things. Twice an hour on the radio, they tell me the level of the Dow Jones and the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ, plus the price of gold and silver and oil. Every week, competing polls tell us who’s likely to win the presidential race. We look at fuel efficiency before we buy a car. We know how many games out of first place our favorite baseball team is. We can now track kids’ grades in school in near-real time, as scores are posted online. And the Census Bureau can tell you how much the average American spends each year on newspapers, video games, and lottery tickets.

And all for what? While polls and labor statistics are meant to help leaders make mid-course corrections, the truth is that much measurement doesn’t matter. As financial planners will tell you, the price of a stock doesn’t matter until the day you sell it. A good coach reminds his team that the only score that matters is the final score. And an isolated quiz or homework score hardly tells the whole picture (which is why wise teachers allow students to drop their lowest grade from the average). Too-frequent measurement leads to skewed results. Would you like to have the meter running on everything you did, capturing you on your worst day? The reason we measure is to analyze – to know “what’s going on” – but if we’re not careful, we can get bogged down and lose sight of the real goal.

All that to say, when it comes to measuring spiritual growth and progress (an awful word, as I’ll explain), we need to be very, very careful. And that’s because spiritual growth is never an individual endeavor. So if a worker’s productivity is low, we normally conclude that they need to work harder. If a student’s grades are low, we conclude they need to study more. If the unemployment rate is high, we try to create more jobs. And so on.

But “How do you measure spiritual growth?” turns out to be not the same question as “How do you promote it?” because we aren’t the Spirit! That should be obvious, but it bears repeating: we are not the Spirit. Instead, we try to be the fertile soil in which the Spirit can grow, but as Paul wrote in the first letter to the Corinthian church: “I planted the seed, Apollos watered it, but God made it grow.”

So what if the “work” of spiritual growth is soil preparation? That way, any credit for the progress goes to God, and we don’t pump ourselves up on false notions that it was our hard work or effort that produced growth. As I wrote last week, just because we might engineer the appearance of the fruits of the Spirit doesn’t mean anything remotely spiritual or supernatural is going on.

So what’s helpful to measure? What might we look to as encouraging signs that spiritual growth is likely to happen? Over the next three weeks, I’ll be breaking down three markers that might be helpful: identity, network, and allegiance.